5 thoughts on “Soviet Russians between Hitler and Stalin

  1. Mr. Enstad. A few questions:

    1) What Russian sources did you use?

    2) Did you have access to Russian archival data?

    3) Have you researched the history of the fascist/nationalist underground in the USSR in the pre-War period of 1920s-30s?

    4) Did you collate the statistical data, such as: a) What overall % of population actively supported/collaborated with the occupational forces? b) What overall % of population sided with the partisans? c) Which % of the population accompanied retreting Wermacht forces? d) How these facets of data for the the N-E part of the RSFSR compare with other parts of the USSR?

    5) According to your profiles on various sites, you are from Oslo’s Uni “Department of Literature, Area Studies and European Languages”, while your “current postdoctoral project focuses on the history of right-wing militancy in post-Soviet Russia”. What’s your graduation diploma says regarding the sphere of your expertise?

    6) Also from the personal data that you freely provide: Researcher, Norwegian Defence Research Establishment (FFI), 2013-15. Care to comment on that?

    • 1, 2) Sources are referenced in my book, they are from several archives in Russia, Germany, and the US, as well as other materials such as oral testimonies, diaries, memoirs. 3) I haven’t researched this topic, no. 4) According to my estimate, by mid-1943 about 15 percent of the male working population served in local self-government apparatus or as police/anti-partisan auxiliaries. At the same time, an estimated 1.5% had joined partisan groups. Yet many more sympathized. And of course, a lot of people simply sided with whomever controlled the area. That often meant “siding” with Germans by day and partisans by night. I think 50-60% accompanied (or were forced along with) the retreating Wehrmacht. I haven’t made systematic comparisons with other occupied territories. 5, 6) Not sure I understand your question here.

  2. Mr. Enstad. How come two of my comments (yesterday’s and today’s) changed their designation from the normal, seen to everyon, into “your comment is awaiting moderation”? I take it, that you are your own “moderation”. Why the change?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s